How to Prevent Having Your Prenup Invalidated in a California Divorce

How to Prevent Having Your Prenup Invalidated in a California divorce

Prenuptial agreements, or prenups, are crucial tools for couples planning to marry, providing clarity and protection concerning financial matters should the marriage end. However, their enforceability can be challenged, leading to potential invalidation. Understanding how prenups can be invalidated and how to avoid these pitfalls is essential for ensuring your agreement stands the test of time.

Common Reasons Prenups Are Invalidated

1. Lack of Voluntariness

One of the most critical aspects of a valid prenup is that both parties must enter into the agreement voluntarily. If one party was coerced or pressured into signing the prenup, it could be deemed invalid. Coercion can be subtle, such as undue pressure from family members or a significant imbalance of power between the parties. To avoid this, ensure that both parties sign the agreement without any external pressure, and consider having each party consult with their own independent legal counsel.

2. Inadequate Disclosure

A prenup requires full and fair disclosure of each party’s financial situation. If one party fails to disclose significant assets or liabilities, or if they provide misleading information, the prenup might be challenged. Full disclosure means providing detailed information about income, assets, debts, and any other financial obligations. Transparency is key; both parties should have a clear and accurate picture of each other's financial circumstances before signing the agreement.

3. Unconscionable Terms

Prenups should contain fair and reasonable terms. If the agreement includes provisions that are deemed unconscionable, a court may invalidate it. There is case law in California about specific clauses and issues that should not be included. To avoid issues surrounding this, ensure that the terms are balanced and fair. This can be a fine line, because “fairness” is subjective and unique to each couple. Consulting with a family law attorney is critical.

4. Absence of Independent Legal Counsel

Each party to a prenup should have their own independent legal representation. Joint representation should not be permitted: it can create conflicts of interest and may lead to claims of unfairness. If one party did not have their own attorney, they might argue that they were not adequately advised about the agreement’s implications. To prevent this issue, ensure both parties have separate legal counsel who can provide independent advice and ensure the agreement is understood and fair.

5. Procedural Irregularities

Prenups must adhere to specific legal formalities to be enforceable. This includes proper signing of the agreement, including compliance with timing requirements. If the agreement was not signed according to legal requirements or if it was signed under duress or without sufficient time for review, it may be challenged. Ensuring that the prenup is signed in accordance with California law, with adequate time for each party to review and consider it, helps avoid procedural issues.

How to Protect the Validity of a Prenup

1. Seek Professional Legal Advice

The best way to ensure your prenup is enforceable is to engage an experienced California family law attorney. An attorney specializing in family law can provide valuable guidance on drafting an agreement that meets legal standards and addresses the couple’s goals. They can also help ensure that the language comports with the couple’s desires and complies with the law.

2. Ensure Full and Accurate Disclosure

Transparency is crucial in a prenup. Both parties should fully disclose their financial information and ensure that the other party has a clear understanding of their assets and liabilities. This openness helps prevent future disputes and ensures that the prenup is based on accurate information.

3. Draft Fair and Balanced Terms, Including a Prevailing Party Attorney Fee Clause

Avoid including clauses that could be considered unconscionable. At the same time, disincentive either party from challenging the agreement by including a prevailing party attorney fee clause.

A prevailing party attorney fee clause is a provision commonly found in contracts, including premarital agreements. This clause stipulates that if a dispute arises and one party prevails in a legal action related to the contract, the losing party will be required to pay the prevailing party’s attorney fees and legal costs.

The clause must be clear and unambiguous. This can encourage compliance with the terms of the agreement and reduce the likelihood of protracted legal battles.

4. Follow Legal Formalities

Adhere to all legal requirements for negotiating and signing the prenup. Ensure that the agreement is executed in compliance with California law, and provide sufficient time for both parties to review the document before signing. This attention to detail helps avoid challenges based on procedural irregularities.

5. Regularly Review and Update

Circumstances change over time, and so can your prenup. Regularly reviewing and updating the agreement to reflect significant life changes—such as the birth of a child or major financial shifts—can help maintain its relevance and enforceability. Periodic updates ensure that the prenup continues to align with both parties’ current situations and intentions.

Conclusion

Prenuptial agreements are valuable tools for managing financial matters and expectations in marriage, but their effectiveness depends on their validity. By understanding the common reasons prenups are invalidated and taking proactive steps to avoid these issues, you can help ensure that your prenup remains enforceable. Seeking professional legal advice, ensuring full disclosure, drafting fair terms, following legal formalities, and regularly reviewing the agreement are key strategies for maintaining the strength and validity of your prenup.

Emily Rubenstein Law PC is a full service divorce and family law firm. We proudly serve Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, West Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Culver City, the South Bay, Glendale, Pasadena, Sherman Oaks, Studio City, Encino and all of Los Angeles County.

Give us a call or check out our website:

(310) 750-0827 | www.emilyrubensteinlaw.com