Are There Any Unique Challenges in Same-Sex Divorce? The Truth About California’s Divorce Laws
In recent years, same-sex marriage and divorce have become more common as legal rights expanded. However, when it comes to divorce, there are still unique challenges that same-sex couples may face. California, known for its progressive stance on LGBTQ+ rights, has made significant strides in ensuring that same-sex couples enjoy the same legal benefits and protections as their heterosexual counterparts. Yet, there are still some nuances in divorce proceedings that may require special attention.
As a Los Angeles family law firm with extensive experience in handling same-sex divorces and premarital agreements, we’ve seen firsthand how the legal landscape for these divorces can differ in specific ways. In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the truth about California’s divorce laws and explore whether there are any unique challenges that same-sex couples face when seeking a divorce.
1. The Legal Landscape for Same-Sex Couples in California
Before delving into the challenges that may arise in a same-sex divorce, it’s essential to understand the legal backdrop that governs these matters in California.
Same-Sex Marriage in California
In California, same-sex marriage became legal on June 28, 2013, after the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Hollingsworth v. Perry (2013), which restored the effect of a federal district court ruling that overturned Proposition 8 as unconstitutional. This was before the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), which ruled that the right to marry is guaranteed to same-sex couples under the Fourteenth Amendment. Prior to the Hollingsworth decision, same-sex couples in California were allowed to enter into domestic partnerships, but they did not have the full legal rights afforded to married couples.
As of 2013, California fully recognized same-sex marriages, and this includes all the rights and responsibilities that come with marriage, such as property division, spousal support, and child custody issues during divorce.
California Divorce Laws
In California, divorce laws are governed by the California Family Code. As of today, same-sex couples are treated the same as heterosexual couples when it comes to divorce proceedings. California is a no-fault divorce state, which means that a spouse does not need to prove fault (such as adultery or abuse) to file for divorce. The most common grounds for divorce are “irreconcilable differences.”
2. Unique Challenges in Same-Sex Divorce
While the legal framework in California for same-sex divorce is largely aligned with heterosexual divorce, there are a few specific challenges that may arise due to historical legal and social factors. These challenges include issues related to the recognition of relationships prior to marriage, complex property division, and child custody concerns. Let’s explore these in greater detail.
2.1. Recognition of Long-Term Relationships Before Marriage
For many same-sex couples, the decision to marry came later in life due to legal restrictions on marriage. This means that many couples who are now divorcing were in long-term relationships prior to marriage but didn’t have the legal framework for divorce until marriage was legalized.
California law allows the division of property acquired during the marriage, but what happens with property and assets acquired prior to the marriage? For same-sex couples, this can be a unique issue, as they may have shared assets or property acquired during their domestic partnership or before they married.
In California, any property or assets obtained during a marriage are generally considered community property, subject to some exceptions. However, assets acquired prior to the marriage may be classified as separate property. For same-sex couples, the challenge comes with proving how assets and property should be divided if they first entered into a domestic partnership or have shared premarital assets. The specific commencement of the community property period may be in dispute.
2.2. Complexity of Property Division
While California is a community property state, meaning all property and assets acquired during the marriage must generally be divided equally, subject to some exceptions, the division of property in a same-sex divorce can still be more complex due to the following factors:
Domestic Partnerships: As mentioned, many same-sex couples were in domestic partnerships prior to marriage legalization. Property acquired during this time may require a separate legal process for division, and the court must decide whether the domestic partnership property should be treated the same as marital property.
Non-Standard Family Structures: Same-sex couples may have non-traditional family structures or shared finances that don’t align with the typical traditional “marriage” framework. This may require more creative legal solutions to divide assets equitably.
It’s also important to note that some assets, such as retirement accounts, pensions, or business interests, may have a more complicated division process in any divorce, but the added challenge in a same-sex divorce could be dealing with these assets from multiple phases of the relationship (i.e., both domestic partnership and marriage).
2.3. Child Custody and Parenting Issues
Another area where same-sex couples might face unique challenges is in child custody and parenting issues. Many same-sex couples have children through adoption, surrogacy, or other means of assisted reproduction. In these cases, one parent may not have a biological connection to the child, which can complicate custody arrangements if the relationship ends in divorce.
In California, both parents in a same-sex marriage are typically recognized as legal parents if the child was born during the marriage or if the couple adopted the child together. However, there can be disputes if one parent did not adopt the child or if the biological parent of the child is not the one seeking custody. This is especially important if one parent wants to move away with the child, as courts will look at what’s in the best interest of the child and what is in line with the child's established relationship with both parents.
For couples who had children before their marriage or domestic partnership, there may be additional legal complexities regarding establishing parental rights and custody.
2.4. Spousal Support
In California, spousal support (also known as alimony) is determined on a case-by-case basis, with considerations for the length of the marriage, each spouse’s needs, and the ability of the other spouse to pay. While the laws regarding spousal support are the same for same-sex couples as for heterosexual couples, determining spousal support can sometimes be more complicated for same-sex couples due to the following:
Length of Relationship: If a same-sex couple was in a long-term relationship before the marriage, there may be a disagreement about whether the court should consider the entire length of the relationship when determining spousal support. This is especially relevant for couples who were together for years but only married later.
Economic Disparities: Some same-sex couples may have faced economic disparities during the earlier years of their relationship due to discrimination or lack of legal recognition. If one spouse was the primary breadwinner while the other stayed home to care for the family, these historical imbalances may impact the support awarded during divorce proceedings.
2.5. Emotional and Social Stigma
While California is progressive in its recognition of LGBTQ+ rights, same-sex couples may still face emotional and social stigma in their divorce process. This may affect both spouses' mental health and well-being, which can in turn impact divorce negotiations, particularly in cases involving child custody or spousal support.
Additionally, some same-sex couples may encounter challenges in finding family law attorneys who are empathetic to their unique concerns or who have experience handling complex same-sex divorce issues. For this reason, it’s important to work with an attorney who has specific experience with LGBTQ+ divorce issues.
3. How to Navigate a Same-Sex Divorce in California
If you're considering divorce in California and you’re in a same-sex marriage or domestic partnership, it’s crucial to approach the process with the help of an experienced family law attorney who understands the intricacies of California's culture and divorce laws as they apply to same-sex couples.
Here are a few steps to help navigate the process:
Understand Your Rights: California recognizes same-sex marriages and domestic partnerships equally under the law. This means you have the same rights to spousal support, property division, and child custody as any heterosexual couple.
Divide Property Carefully: Make sure you have a clear understanding of what qualifies as community property and separate property. Be prepared to provide documentation of the assets you and your spouse acquired during the relationship, both before and after marriage.
Work Out Parenting Arrangements: If you have children, it’s essential to determine the best arrangements for custody and visitation. If one parent is not the biological parent, you may need legal assistance to establish parental rights.
Seek Emotional and Legal Support: Divorce can be an emotionally charged process, particularly when complex family dynamics are involved. This can be even more difficult in light of social stigmas and discrimination. Make sure you have both legal and emotional support to get through the process.
4. Conclusion
Same-sex divorce in California largely follows the same rules and procedures as heterosexual divorce. However, there are unique challenges, including complications regarding property division, spousal support, child custody, recognition of relationships prior to marriage, discrimination, and stigma. Understanding these complexities and having the right legal support can make a significant difference in ensuring a fair and smooth divorce process.
If you are facing a same-sex divorce in California, it's essential to consult with a knowledgeable family law attorney who has experience handling the specific issues that arise in these cases. The right lawyer can help you navigate the intricacies of California’s divorce laws and secure a favorable outcome.
--
Emily Rubenstein Law PC is a full service divorce and family law firm. We proudly serve Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, West Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Culver City, the South Bay, Glendale, Pasadena, Sherman Oaks, Studio City, Encino and all of Los Angeles County.
Give us a call or check out our website:
(310) 750-0827 | www.emilyrubensteinlaw.com